7 Romantic Dinner Date Spots in Brooklyn Heights

7 Romantic Dinner Date Spots in Brooklyn Heights

  • Caryl Berenato
  • 06/25/23

With its charming brownstone-lined streets and awe-inspiring views of the Manhattan skyline, Brooklyn Heights provides the perfect setting for an enchanting and romantic dinner date. Renowned for its historic allure and one-of-a-kind ambiance, this neighborhood exudes romance. Whether you prefer intimate bistros on quiet streets or waterfront gems boasting breathtaking vistas, Brooklyn Heights offers many options to suit your preferences.

These handpicked dinner date spots in Brooklyn Heights have been thoughtfully curated to provide diverse options, each ensuring an unforgettable experience. Read on to plan your date night at the best restaurants in Brooklyn Heights.

The River Cafe

1 Water St, Brooklyn, NY

On the edge of Brooklyn Heights and jutting out from the Promenade over the East River, The River Cafe is an iconic restaurant that embodies romance and sophistication. Its privileged location on the water offers breathtaking views of the Brooklyn Bridge and the stunning Manhattan skyline. As you enter this charming restaurant, an elegant atmosphere, including flickering candlelight and live piano music, greets you.

River Cafe received a Michelin star for a good reason. Savor the dishes carefully prepared with the finest ingredients, such as foie gras terrine, fallow venison loin, and goat cheese cheesecake. Each dish is a veritable work of art delighting the palate. Impeccable service and unforgettable surroundings make The River Café a compelling choice for a romantic dinner. The three-course dinner experience is set at $195 per guest.


127 Atlantic Ave, Brooklyn, NY 

Colonie is a high-end gem exuding warmth and intimacy tucked away on Atlantic Avenue. The rustic yet modern decor, featuring exposed brick and industrial details, harkens to artists' lofts and Bohemian life. The interior also incorporates fine dining fixtures and accessories and reminds diners of colonial-era New York City. The charming restaurant is ideal for a romantic dinner date, reflecting their farm-to-table concept by incorporating locally sourced ingredients into every dish.

Pappardelle pasta served with locally sourced milk-braised lamb makes mouths water, and the Atlantic hake is a stunner. Expect fresh and vibrant flavors that are thoughtfully prepared. Enhance your dining experience by pairing your meal with a selection from their impressive wine list, or indulge in one of their signature cocktails. With an attentive staff and a seductive atmosphere, Colonie is the perfect place to create unforgettable dinner memories.

Noodle Pudding

38 Henry St, Brooklyn, NY

For a taste of classic Italian cuisine and distinctive, old-world charm, Noodle Pudding is the go-to destination. Situated on Henry Street, this cozy trattoria offers an intimate atmosphere that transports you back in time. You will feel like you're in 1950s Brooklyn or Italy itself. The ambiance is undeniably romantic with its exposed brick walls, soft lighting, and flickering candles.

Indulge in the menu's authentic Italian dishes, like pacherri in a Sunday gravy or hand-cut linguini, aromatic seafood, and tender cuts of meat. The warm, neighborly hospitality and genuine flavors make Noodle Pudding a beloved choice for couples searching for a romantic evening in Brooklyn Heights.

Henry's End

72 Henry St, Brooklyn, NY

As a beloved local establishment for over 50 years, Henry's End continues to captivate visitors with its comforting atmosphere and exceptional cuisine. Step inside and be welcomed by the warm glow of candlelight and the enticing aroma of delectable dishes like a duckling with honey ginger or walnut-crusted chicken breast. Renowned for its diverse menu, Henry's End offers something for every palate. After one bite, it will be obvious why their roast duck is famous, as well as their hearty steaks and innovative seafood creations. The welcoming staff will ensure that your dining experience is nothing short of delightful and that you will enjoy a romantic evening.


Pier 6 Brooklyn Bridge Park, Brooklyn, NY

Nestled in the heart of Brooklyn Heights, Pilot is an absolute gem. This extraordinary dining establishment delivers not only excellent cuisine but also a truly unique experience. Set on a historic ship moored on the water, Pilot's provides a singular dining experience with sweeping vistas of the New York City skyline. Indulge yourself in the warm and intimate ambiance as you savor a thoughtfully curated menu showcasing a blend of seasonal ingredients and innovative flavors. From tempting seafood creations to impressively crafted cocktails, Pilot Restaurant is a delight.


185 Atlantic Ave, Brooklyn, NY

Brooklyn Heights denizens flock to the Middle-eastern-infused New American cuisine at Boutros. The proprietor Allen Dabagh draws from his Lebanese and Syrian heritage to create satisfying, enticing dishes such as American Wagyu kebab, Moulard duck breast, and duck fat batata harra. The restaurant's interior, design choices, and decor engender a romantic mood, with dimmed lighting only provided by single lightbulbs suspended from the ceiling.

Chez Moi

135 Atlantic Ave, Brooklyn, NY 

A charming French restaurant in Brooklyn Heights, Chez Moi transports patrons to the streets of Paris once they walk inside. The intimate ambiance sets the stage for a romantic dining experience. Indulge in their succulent lamb couscous, where tender lamb joins aromatic couscous for a flavor explosion. If you are in the mood for a classic steak dish, their New York strip steak frites are a must-try, featuring a juicy and perfectly cooked steak accompanied by crispy golden fries. For those craving bold flavors, their Thai coconut curry mussels are sure to satisfy, with plump mussels swimming in a fragrant coconut curry broth. Of course, sip a glass of fine French wine to complement your meal.

Work with a quality real estate agent

Working with real estate agent Caryl Berenato is invaluable for successfully navigating the Brooklyn Heights real estate market. Caryl's local market expertise and commitment to understanding your unique needs and desires ensure a seamless and rewarding home-buying experience. With a deep understanding of the neighborhood and its real estate landscape, she will guide you through every step, from initial consultation to final negotiation. Caryl's dedication, professionalism, and personalized approach ensure your search for a home in Brooklyn Heights will be an exciting and rewarding journey. Contact her today.

Work With Us

Caryl built an unparalleled knowledge base and tool kit of resources to address any obstacles that may arise, and she has a strong network of professional contacts she readily shares with her clients.